5 Comments
User's avatar
Happy's avatar

Ok HaRav Mecharker, what does it say on Natan's blog?

Expand full comment
Test's avatar

You claim that all non kollel families are the same as the modox. It's either kollel or modox. Where are the articles supporting that? Are the children of your typical Monsey chareidi accountant/businessman/whatever texting on Shabbos?

Expand full comment
מכרכר בכל עוז's avatar

Who claims that?? I certainly never did! Did Mr. Ciment imply as such in his article? If so, I did not notice it. Can you show me which line you are referring to?

Expand full comment
Yakov's avatar

'Why do a large number of the high school and Modern Orthodox college kids who attended Jewish day schools text on Shabbos, or worse?'

He said ot already: because they are brought up in a society where Torah is of secondary importance and are exposed to forbidden entertainment, dress and confusing messages. מה יעשה בן ולא אחטא?

Expand full comment
Yakov's avatar

There is a subculture in the Chassidic and Litvish world that does all the same things. Some keep the outward apperances, others don't. It's not an insignificant percentage.

How do people in these communities know the news of the events that are happening on Shabbos?

Expand full comment