15 Comments
User's avatar
מכרכר בכל עוז's avatar

Truly academic brilliance. I think Dr. Shapiro is going to start having an inferiority complex.

Expand full comment
Ash's avatar

So what's Natan's new post? Please summarize!

Expand full comment
Ash's avatar

The transliteration is perfect, btw. Ya'asheyr Ko'akh!

Expand full comment
Happy's avatar

Wow, that article is something else. The logic is impeccable

אם היינו מבקשים להוציא מאזכורו של הכלל בסוגיה מסקנה

מעשית כלשהי, היה עלינו להסיק שאין על נשים להינשא

משום שאין אפוטרופוס לעריות וייתכן שהן תתייחדנה עם

אנשים אחרים )בין מרצון בין מאונס( בכל מצב שהוא.

With logic like that, what else do you need?

But I think Rabbi Cherlow would be very pleased with my new heter.

Expand full comment
Happy's avatar

Also, I love how he spends like half the article insisting that he is most definitely, most certainly not trying to say halacha has changed, not at all, no siree.

Expand full comment
מרכבות פרעה's avatar

There should be some sort of disclaimer, in case somebody left their sense of humor at the mechanic.

Expand full comment
תורת המן's avatar

Beautifully done!!

Be careful of Poe's Law though

Expand full comment
Yekutiel Weiss's avatar

Ramaz was never considered a place for religious students to attend. It had a high percentage of students from non religious families. In the last perhaps ten years more Shomerei Shabbat send their children there. You are criticizing more inclusive schools and congregants who have become more religious. Thank G-d for this improvement.

Expand full comment
Boruch H.'s avatar

It actually shtims very nicely with the other way Chazal use the term "derekh eretz"...

Expand full comment
Yaacov Lyons's avatar

We need some more like this one. Its Gadlus!

Expand full comment
DD's avatar

N.S. actually sends his very own children to mixed youth groups, he wrote about this.

Expand full comment
y ch's avatar

On target. oy

Expand full comment
Evil Blob's avatar

LOLOLOLOL!!!

🤣🤣🤣🤣

Expand full comment
Ben's avatar

The problem is that some people won’t get the joke.

Expand full comment